Skip to content
Gabriel Zucman@gabriel_zucman · Oct 5, 2026

As voting begins today, the world needs to know what Silicon Valley billionaires are doing to sabotage the billionaire…

19 tweets2 min read♥ 2.6Koriginal

Summary

Silicon Valley billionaires are spending over $230 million on misleading advertising and using multiple tactics to defeat California's proposed 5% wealth tax on billionaires (Prop 40), including funding poison-pill ballot measures, spreading misinformation, and hiding their donations through shell organizations. The campaign involves false claims about threats to healthcare and middle-class savings while the billionaires funnel enormous sums through organizations designed to obscure their identities.

Summarized by ThreadOut AI from the full thread. May miss nuance — read the thread below.

  1. #1

    As voting begins today, the world needs to know what Silicon Valley billionaires are doing to sabotage the billionaire tax now on the ballot in California. This is shocking. 🧵

  2. #2

    California’s 250 billionaires know they have little chance of winning a referendum in which 20 million voters are asked to approve a tax of 5% on billionaires’ wealth to fund health care and education. So, what do they do? Sergey Brin (Google co-founder), @patrickc (Stripe co-founder), @peterthiel , @ericschmidt and others have devised an extraordinary array of schemes to manipulate the vote.

  3. #3

    First tactic: prevent the vote from happening at all (!!). Panicked at the prospect of paying taxes, the billionaires did everything they could to prevent the measure from being put on the ballot. They poured enormous sums of money into efforts to prevent the health care union SEIU-UHW from gathering the required signatures, then enlisted California Governor @GavinNewsom to get the proposal withdrawn. Fortunately, all these maneuvers failed miserably: the vote is happening, and it begins today.

  4. #4

    Second tactic: unleash a tsunami of misleading ads. The billionaires have already spent $230 million. Sergey Brin alone has spent $138 million. @patrickc : $20 million. @ericschmidt : $15 million. It is one of the most expensive campaigns in U.S. history. The billionaires have reserved nearly $100 million worth of advertising, compared with roughly $100,000 for supporters of the tax. And they are nowhere near finished. Voting begins today—80% of Californians vote by mail—and runs through November 3, Election Day for the midterms. The advertising tsunami will only intensify between now and then.

  5. #5

    Third tactic: turn the threat on its head. The tax affects 250 California billionaires? Yet the people appearing in ads to oppose it aren’t Brin or Zuckerberg, but… doctors in white coats. The tax is intended to offset Trump’s devastating cuts to Medicaid, the federal health insurance program for low-income Americans? The ads claim that passing the tax would threaten California’s health care system. It is an astonishing inversion of reality.

  6. #6

    Three million Californians will lose their health coverage as soon as next year if the billionaire tax does not pass. Yet according to this campaign, it is passing the billionaire tax that poses the greatest threat to California’s health care system (!!). It is an old trick: convince people that the cure will make the disease worse. Here is the main ad flooding California television and social media right now. Orwellian.

  7. #7

    Fourth tactic: divide the opposition. One of the billionaires’ challenges is to undermine what makes the pro-billionaire-tax campaign so strong: the simplicity of the issue—taxing 250 fabulously wealthy and undertaxed billionaires—and the enormous popular support for this type of proposal. So they use proxies to try to turn a conflict between “billionaires and everyone else” into a fight between “health care advocates versus other health care advocates.” This mailer sent to California’s 20 million voters is a striking example.

  8. #8

    The $100 billion in revenue the billionaire tax would raise for hospitals is somehow presented as an unprecedented threat to hospitals. A staggering inversion of reality. Fortunately, many members of Planned Parenthood have distanced themselves from executive @jodihicks , who chose to lend her face and credibility as a spokesperson to this grotesque operation. But the damage has been done. Millions of California voters are being misled into believing that Prop 40 will somehow put their health care system at risk.

  9. #9

    Fifth tactic: neutralize a YES victory. The billionaires are not merely trying to defeat Prop 40. By pouring tens of millions of dollars into gathering 2 million signatures, they also managed to qualify two poison-pill bills for the ballot: Prop 41 and Prop 42. According to some sources, they even went so far as to pay homeless people (!!) to gather the signatures needed to qualify Props 41 and 42. The only purpose of these two countermeasures is to nullify the billionaire tax if either one receives more votes than Prop 40. Yes, you read that correctly.

  10. #10

    Voters are being deliberately misled by the billionaires. On the surface, Prop 41 calls for state government audits, while Prop 42 promises to protect savings and retirement accounts from taxation. This looks appealing on the surface but makes no sense: there are already audits in place, and no plan to tax retirement savings. The only goal of Prop 41 and Prop 42 is to nullify the billionaire tax if it passes. Yet their campaign materials mention neither Prop 40 nor billionaires. As a result, most voters do not realize that passing these measures could nullify a “yes” on Prop 40. Current polls show majorities supporting all three measures at the same time—Prop 40, Prop 41, and Prop 42. We have therefore reached the absurd situation in which the billionaire tax could be approved and overturned by the very same voters on the very same day, due to misinformation.

  11. #11

    Sixth tactic: turn a tax on billionaires into a tax that supposedly threatens everyone. That’s a classic. The billionaires’ campaign claims that the tax would open the door to taxing everyone’s savings and retirement accounts. That is obviously false–no one, anywhere, is advocating for taxing the wealth of the middle class. The goal is simple: make every voter feel personally threatened by a tax… that does not and will never apply to them. As this widely aired ad illustrates, their messaging strategy is designed to get voters to reject the tax while believing they are protecting their own interests—not those of billionaires.

  12. #12

    Seventh tactic: manufacture fake threats. Opponents pretend that the tax risks causing an “exodus” of billionaires. They point to several billionaires who supposedly left California already. These cases are intended to make the threat of an exodus more vivid and credible. But Prop 40, by design, cannot cause such a flight. It is one-time tax – not an annual tax. It would only apply to billionaires who were residents of California as of January 1, 2026. Billionaires had just a few weeks between the initiative’s announcement at the end of November 2025 and January 1, 2026, to leave. Experts agree that it was virtually impossible for any billionaire to successfully become a non-resident for tax purposes in such a short period of time. A case in point: Sergey Brin claimed he left, yet he is pouring more than $100 million against Prop 40… Why spend so much against a tax he wouldn’t have to pay? The reason is that he could not avoid the tax – and would be on the hook for more than $10 billion if Prop 40 passes.

  13. #13

    The Hoover Institution, in a deceptive study, claimed the tax would end up costing more than it brings. To reach that conclusion, the authors of the study assumed that the tax would become annual. Hence, on the cost side, some billionaires would leave California. However, on the benefits side, if the tax becomes annual it would generate revenue annually. But the Hoover economists did not take that into account. You read that correctly: they assumed the tax would be annual, leading to some outflows, but that it would bring revenue only once. This makes no sense – but usefully fuels the anti-tax ads.

    Gabriel Zucman@gabriel_zucman · Jul 5, 2026

    Now that the California billionaire tax is officially on the ballot this November, voters deserve logical arguments. This guest essay in today’s New York Times, by two economists from the Hoover Institution, is based on a shocking logical mistake. 🧵

  14. #14

    Eighth tactic: hide the billionaires. If you look at this sign, you will notice the names of Prop 40’s major funders, including the leading progressive figure Saikat Chakrabarti (@saikatc). That disclosure is required by law. Yet—and as incredible as this may sound—you will not see the name of a single billionaire in the No campaign. Sergey Brin’s name does not appear dierctly, even though he has contributed more than $100 million. How is that possible?

  15. #15

    For a simple reason: Brin funnels his donations through an organization with the innocuous-sounding name “Building a Better California,” which in turn funds the campaign committees working to defeat the billionaire tax. As a result, Sergey Brin’s name does not show up as funding the opposition to Prop 40. More broadly, California’s billionaires have organized themselves behind generic, positive-sounding names, depriving voters of the most useful piece of information of all: who is paying for the campaign. The letter of the law is being followed, while its purpose is being gutted.

  16. #16

    To win this referendum, Silicon Valley’s billionaires are trying to stay out of sight. That is precisely why we need to shine a brighter spotlight on them than ever before. Since 1982, the wealth of California’s billionaires—the richest 0.0002%—has increased thirtyfold. It rose by 144% between 2023 and 2025 alone. California billionaires now hold $2.4 trillion in wealth, equivalent to 50% of California’s GDP. The wealth of these 250 billionaires is as big as the total income reported by all California families on their individual income tax returns – some 20 million of them.

  17. #17

    You might assume that fortunes this enormous would translate into equally enormous tax bills. They do not. According to a study we have just conducted, California billionaires pay the equivalent of just 0.2% of their wealth in California income taxes each year—amounting to barely 3% of the state’s total income tax revenue. They contribute a negligible amount to the state that made them rich. It is as though they live in a parallel society.

  18. #18

    For example, in 2019, 2020, and 2023, Sergey Brin and Larry Page—the co-founders of Google and, respectively, the second- and third-richest people in the world—reported no income and paid no income tax on their colossal Alphabet-derived wealth. Since 2019, their combined wealth has increased by more than $400 billion. Sergey Brin is now spending tens of millions of dollars to defeat the proposed billionaire tax.

  19. #19

    The California ballot is a major political battle—arguably one of the most important battles in the U.S. midterm elections. As extreme wealth continues to explode worldwide, California is now emerging as the battleground in the fight for global tax justice. The vote now getting underway could mark the beginning of a global movement to end the ultra-rich’s ability to escape taxation with impunity. Please help spread the word about the tactics Silicon Valley’s billionaires are using to protect their wealth and undermine democracy.