Skip to content
Gabriel Zucman@gabriel_zucman · Oct 10, 2026

ICE is hunting down immigrants with the help of Palantir. In six months, Palantir’s founder, @PeterThiel, will be able…

20 tweets2 min read♥ 2.9Koriginal

Summary

Peter Thiel has exploited a loophole in Roth IRA rules since 1999 to accumulate an estimated $5+ billion tax-free, and in six months when he turns 59½ he'll be able to withdraw these funds completely tax-free to fund political causes. California's Proposition 40 billionaire wealth tax could close this loophole, but Thiel is fighting it with millions in donations and opposing ballot measures.

Summarized by ThreadOut AI from the full thread. May miss nuance — read the thread below.

  1. #1

    ICE is hunting down immigrants with the help of Palantir. In six months, Palantir’s founder, @PeterThiel, will be able to start spending unimaginable sums of money —completely tax-free — to bankroll the political causes dear to his heart. He'll be able to do it thanks to a tax-avoidance scheme he’s been building for more than 20 years, at a staggering cost to the American taxpayer. Let me explain. 🧵

  2. #2

    Before we begin, understand this: time is running out. Tomorrow, @PeterThiel turns 59. And when he turns 59½—just six months from now—he'll be able to claim an extraordinary victory he's been quietly working toward since 1999. But there's still a way to stop him. The countdown has begun.

  3. #3

    It all starts in 1997. Republican Senator William Roth Jr. pushes through legislation creating the Roth IRA, a retirement savings account designed to help middle-class Americans build tax-free retirement savings. At the time, eligibility was limited to Americans earning less than $110,000 a year, and annual contributions were capped at $2,000.

  4. #4

    In 1999, @PeterThiel earned $73,263 a year at PayPal. That made him eligible to open a Roth IRA. And that’s exactly what he did. But not to put away $2,000 a year for retirement. Instead, he set out to build an extraordinary tax-avoidance machine.

  5. #5

    Thiel had his Roth IRA buy @PayPal shares for a tiny fraction of a penny each: 1.7 million shares for just… $1,700. That's $0.001 per share. The price was low enough for him to place 1.7 million shares in his Roth IRA while staying below the $2,000 Roth IRA maximum contribution limit.

  6. #6

    We don’t know how he was allowed to do that. @PayPal had just been created so, arguably, its value was uncertain and low. But PayPal was already raising funds. One month after this transfer, the company sold shares to investors for $500,000, at a valuation far higher than $0.001 per share. In just one year, the value of Thiel’s Roth IRA jumped from $1,700 to $3.8 million. Yet he was able to buy and transfer 1.7 million shares at $0.001 each.

  7. #7

    The shares then kept appreciating at a staggering pace, and the Roth IRA has allowed Thiel to diversify his wealth and invest tax free ever since then. In 2002, he sold his PayPal shares. Because they were held in a Roth IRA, he paid no tax on the enormous capital gain. He then reinvested the proceeds by buying shares of @PalantirTech , @facebook , and many other investments. In 2019, the stock portfolio in his Roth IRA was worth $5 billion spread across 96 subaccounts, according to @propublica.

  8. #8

    If @peterthiel owned this enormous stock portfolio directly, outside of an IRA, he would owe 23.8% of his gains in federal taxes, plus another 13.3% in California state taxes, each time he sold shares and realized a capital gain. Instead, he’s been free to sell and buy stocks free of tax, depriving the U.S. Treasury of billions in tax revenue.

  9. #9

    After 1999, Thiel never contributed another dollar to his Roth IRA. He didn't need to. He could simply use the money in his Roth IRA to invest in other Silicon Valley startups and in his own hedge fund – and grow his wealth exponentially.

  10. #10

    It’s obviously much easier to grow one’s wealth when one does not have to pay taxes. When ProPublica exposed the scandal, the assets in his Roth IRA were worth $5 billion. Today they could well be worth $20 billion or $30 billion or more. His total wealth is estimated to be close to $40 billion.

  11. #11

    This is similar to how billionaires in Europe use holding companies to avoid tax – perpetually reinvesting tax free. Retirement accounts originally designed for middle-class Americans have become massive tax shelters for billionaires like Thiel—right here in the United States. But it’s in fact worse than that. Because here’s the catch.

  12. #12

    In a traditional IRA (as opposed to a Roth IRA), people must pay taxes when they withdraw money during retirement. In Europe, billionaires must pay taxes when they withdraw money from their holding companies to fund their personal expenditures. But in 6 months, @peterthiel will be able to withdraw money from his Roth IRA completely tax free. He will be free to use its billions in any way he likes: not just for investment, but for funding political campaigns, candidates for office, “think tanks”, any type of spending he wants.

  13. #13

    Before age 59½, money in a Roth IRA can only be used for investing: if @peterthiel withdrew it for personal spending, he would have had to pay tax plus a 10% early-withdrawal penalty. Once he turns 59½, he will be able to withdraw Roth IRA money completely tax-free. Thiel turns 59 tomorrow.

  14. #14

    In other words, six months from now, the tax-avoidance strategy @peterthiel has been methodically building since 1999 will have achieved its ultimate goal. And the US may be on the verge of a tsunami of political spending by one of America’s most extreme right-wing billionaires, openly hostile to democracy.

  15. #15

    At this point, there is only one thing standing between Thiel and his dream of enjoying his immense fortune tax free forever: Proposition 40. If Californians vote for the billionaire wealth tax, they could finally force him to pay tax. That’s why Thiel is fighting Prop 40 tooth and nail. He's donated $3 million to oppose it and has made a show of moving to Florida to escape California's proposed billionaire wealth tax.

  16. #16

    Like a few other billionaires, he has tried to create the impression that he’s moved out of California, to give credibility to the idea of a billionaire “exodus”. This makes little sense: the billionaire tax would be owed by any billionaire who was a resident of California as of January 1, 2026. Leaving California for tax purposes isn't as simple as buying real estate in Florida or moving companies. The top experts believe that no billionaire was able to successfully become a non-resident between the initiative’s announcement, in November 2025, and January 1, 2026.

  17. #17

    Thiel and his fellow billionaires have used another trick: qualifying two poison-pill measures – Propositions 41 and 42 – for the ballot. Prop 42 is particularly deceptive: it is advertised as a way to protect Californians from a tax on their retirement savings. In reality, its sole goal is to void Prop 40 – the California billionaire wealth tax. No one, anywhere, advocates for taxing middle-class wealth. The only pension wealth that would be taxed by Prop 40 is Thiel’s Roth IRA billions.

  18. #18

    Many other ultra-wealthy Americans have used this and other tax-avoidance strategies to accumulate billions tax free. California voters now have a historic opportunity to play catch-up on these outrageous loopholes and ask billionaires to pay a tax equal to 5% of their wealth.

  19. #19

    If Californians vote YES on Prop 40 and NO on Props 41 and 42, they'll have a chance to make Palantir founder @PeterThiel and other tech billionaires—including Trump-aligned figures like Sergey Brin—finally pay tax. This won’t be enough – they have avoided so much tax over the years – but it would be a start: the beginning of a new form of taxation that brings billionaires back into society.

  20. #20

    Voting NO on Prop 40 means siding with Peter Thiel. Voting YES on Props 41 and 42 means siding with MAGA billionaires. Please share this thread and help spread the word.