Skip to content
Nathan Livingstone (MilkBarTV)@TheMilkBarTV · Sep 21, 2026

The WORST Ukraine War predictions by anti-Western so-called “experts” that have aged terribly. A thread. 🧵 1.…

4 tweets1 min read♥ 3.2Koriginal

Summary

A compilation of wildly inaccurate predictions made by prominent anti-Western analysts and experts about the Ukraine war from 2022-2026, including political scientist John Mearsheimer, military expert Douglas Macgregor, economist Jeffrey Sachs, and journalists Max Blumenthal and Aaron Mate, all of whom repeatedly predicted Ukrainian defeat or imminent Russian victory that failed to materialize.

Summarized by ThreadOut AI from the full thread. May miss nuance — read the thread below.

  1. #1

    The WORST Ukraine War predictions by anti-Western so-called “experts” that have aged terribly. A thread. 🧵 1. Political scientist, John Mearsheimer. Feb. 2022: "I don't think Russia is going to invade." Sep. 2023: "The Ukrainians are doomed to lose." Jan. 2024: "It's ridiculous to think Ukraine can hold the line in 2024." Apr. 2025: "It's unimaginable Ukraine will hang on beyond 2025." Jul. 2026: "The Russians are slowly moving forward."

  2. #2

    2. Military expert, former Colonel Douglas Macgregor. March 2022: "In ten days, this should be completely over." September 2023: "This could go on till Christmas." May 2025: "Over the next month or two, I wouldn't be surprised if the whole picture changes suddenly." August 2026: "This thing is over."

  3. #3

    3. Economist, Jeffrey Sachs. Sep. 2024: "Russia will win this war." Feb. 2025: "The war is ending. It's over." Apr. 2026: "The war is not over by any means at all."

  4. #4

    4. The Grayzone's journalists Max Blumenthal and Aaron Mate. 2022: Hosting and laughing with Russia’s Deputy Ambassador to the UN at the idea that Russia would invade Ukraine: “These alleged plans to invade come as a total surprise to us [Russia].” 2023: Putin will take Odesa by 2024 and bring about Ukraine’s defeat: “This war is on its last legs.” 2024: “Ukraine’s military is collapsing. It’s over.” 2025: “I would give it months.” 2026: Ukraine has had some "tactical victories", but them winning is “impossible now heading into winter.”