Skip to content
Dan Neidle@DanNeidle · Nov 7, 2026

On Thursday I wrote about the 2014 injunction Russell Brand obtained against a woman who accused him of assault. I've…

16 tweets2 min read♥ 9.7Koriginal

Summary

An investigation reveals that Russell Brand obtained a permanent injunction in 2014 against a woman who accused him of assault, silencing her for life without a trial or legal representation, even prohibiting her from speaking to police. The overly broad order functioned as a libel injunction disguised as a harassment injunction, raising serious questions about judicial oversight and how the legal system can be weaponized to suppress speech.

Summarized by ThreadOut AI from the full thread. May miss nuance — read the thread below.

  1. #1

    On Thursday I wrote about the 2014 injunction Russell Brand obtained against a woman who accused him of assault. I've now obtained the final order. It's breathtaking. She had no lawyer. No trial. Yet she was silenced for life - even barred from speaking to the police. 🧵:

  2. #2

    Why? Because Brand (and his then-girlfriend, Jemima Goldsmith) obtained a permanent, life-long, injunction against the woman, Sylvie Berki. Brand/Goldsmith said her accusations amounted to harassment, which caused them "anxiety and distress".

  3. #3

    There wasn't a full trial, just a summary judgment in which the judge didn't determine if Ms Berki's accusations were true, but said she had harassed Brand and Goldsmith Ms Berki had no lawyer.

  4. #4

    What should have happened was an injunction preventing Ms Berki from harassing Brand/Goldsmith. The injunction goes much, much, further. Ms Berki was forbidden from telling *anyone*. Narrow exceptions: her legal advisers and named doctors. She can't speak to the police.

  5. #5

    It looks like the intention was then to bankrupt Ms Berki. The judge had mentioned she had no money, but the order says:

  6. #6

    The full document is published on our website (link at the end) The injunction contains reporting restrictions; the specific accusations contained in a Confidential Schedule can't be repeated. So I can't publish that.

  7. #7

    In substance this wasn't a harassment injunction at all. It was a libel injunction in disguise. That's outrageous because (1) you can't usually get a libel injunction at all, and (2) even in the rate cases you can, the defendant gets to argue they were telling the truth.

  8. #8

    You'd expect the judgment would contain the discussion of whether these restrictions were necessary and proportionate (or even lawful). It does not. A lawyer would have raised these points. Ms Berki had no lawyer.

  9. #9

    Ms Berki tried to appeal the injunction, initially on her own and then again this year with support from a pro bono barrister. (Full judgments in our report) But appealing a decision like this is very hard. She really needs to apply to vary the injunction.

  10. #10

    I understand Jemima Goldsmith is willing to agree to the injunction being varied. I very much doubt Russell Brand is; so Ms Berki would need to fund an expensive application (or have an unusual amount of pro bono support) The injunction makes crowdfunding very difficult.

  11. #11

    The firm acting for Messrs Brand and Goldsmith was Archerfield Partners LLP. We think they have serious questions to answer.

  12. #12

    How could lawyers justify asking a court to prohibit speech that couldn't conceivably constitute harassment - including private conversations with friends and family, and reports to the police?

  13. #13

    And for the judiciary: how could a judge grant such an order against an unrepresented defendant, without a trial, without determining whether her allegations were true and without, it seems, any assessment of proportionality?

  14. #14

    Then the scary question: Was this a one-off? Or have other injunctions been granted, supposedly to prevent harassment, but actually silencing people - even in private conversations with friends, family and the police? I don't know if there's any way to find out.

  15. #15

    Our full report is here, including a complete copy of the injunction (minus the Confidential Schedule) and three appeal documents. taxpolicy.org.uk/2026/11/07/rus…

  16. #16

    I usually investigate tax. But I also care deeply about how the legal system can be used to silence people - not least because others have tried to use it to silence us. Our free newsletter: taxpolicy.org.uk/subscribe/?utm…