Skip to content
A Midwestern Doctor@MidwesternDoc · Nov 6, 2026

New York repealed its religious exemption for school vaccines in 2019, then fined three one-room Amish schools…

8 tweets1 min read♥ 2.4Koriginal

Summary

New York fined three Amish schools $118,000 for refusing to comply with vaccine mandates after repealing religious exemptions. The thread claims unvaccinated Amish children show significantly lower rates of chronic health conditions like asthma and ADHD compared to vaccinated children, and argues the state's allowance of medical exemptions while banning religious ones violates religious neutrality.

Summarized by ThreadOut AI from the full thread. May miss nuance — read the thread below.

  1. #1

    New York repealed its religious exemption for school vaccines in 2019, then fined three one-room Amish schools $118,000. Their lawyer surveyed the roughly 160 children at those schools. You'd expect about nine cases of asthma alone. What they found instead: those children had zero of the chronic conditions plaguing American kids. 🧵

  2. #2

    An Oregon pediatrician compared 2,763 vaccinated children with 561 unvaccinated ones born into his practice. ADHD wasn't found in any of the unvaccinated children. Publishing that cost him his medical license: midwesterndoctor.com/p/how-much-dam…

  3. #3

    The Court already sent it back once, in light of its 2025 parental-rights decision. The appeals court ruled against the Amish again on June 30, 2026, and their new petition was filed September 28.

  4. #4

    New York still allows medical exemptions. It just doesn't allow religious ones. That's the core of the families' argument: if you can opt out for medical reasons, a rule that bans religious objections isn't neutral toward religion. As one of their advocates put it: "who is the authority over your children? Is it the parents or is the government bureaucrat?"

  5. #5

    Aaron Siri: "There are approximately 10 or so studies that have done that compared kids with no exposure, meaning zero vaccines, to kids that have had one or more vaccines" and they "show the same outcome." Zero vaccines: almost none of the chronic health issues. One or more: multiple rates of them.

  6. #6

    Vaccination has many of the trappings of a religion: doctors as priests, hospitals as temples, and vaccines as the holy water baptizing you into the faith. That's why a religious objection to it is treated as heresy: midwesterndoctor.com/p/dissecting-t…

  7. #7

    Roughly 160 Amish children, and none of the chronic conditions you'd expect. New York's response was $118,000 in fines. The data they won't collect: midwesterndoctor.com/p/how-much-dam…

  8. #8

    If the Amish lose, no religious family anywhere is safe from a mandate. I'm following this case to the end. Give me (@MidwesternDoc) a follow and visit me on Substack! midwesterndoctor.com