why nobody fights in fics anymore, a 🧵:
Summary
Modern fanfiction often lacks realistic arguments because writers prioritize keeping characters likeable over authentic conflict, sanitizing disputes where everyone has valid points and no one gets hurt. Real relationships involve characters being unfair, petty, or wrong temporarily, and compelling fights require understanding why each character reacts as they do rather than writing convenient plot resolutions.
Summarized by ThreadOut AI from the full thread. May miss nuance — read the thread below.
- #1
why nobody fights in fics anymore, a 🧵:
Star ⭐️🔞@staropia_ · Oct 16, 2026What’s with fanfictions and never being able to write realistic arguments between couples?
- #2
quick clarification before someone silly comes for me: i am not referring to actual abuse, just to verbal arguments in general, aka moments when one says shit that hurts the other's feelings, like OP pointed out. okay? good!
- #3
truth is, a convincing argument almost always requires allowing your characters to be the "bad guys" for a second. to be unfair, petty, defensive, hypocritical, irrational, manipulative, avoidant, cruel, or simply just wrong for while. because that's just how real arguments are.
- #4
mind you, a character being the "bad guy" in an argument doesn't mean the story has to condemn them as a bad person. but a lot of writers seem to feel pressure to prove that their characters are "good people." which may feel pleasant, but never actually real.
- #5
so what do writers do when they don't wanna write an argument? conflict gets sanitized, everyone has a valid point, everyone is perfectly understandable, nobody crosses a line, and nobody has to sit with having genuinely hurt someone. so, essentially, the argument goes *poof*.
- #6
and i DO get the age/inexperience point. younger or less experienced writers may not have much firsthand reference for long-term rs conflict, so they most rely on media templates: dramatic misunderstandings, cheating accusations, overheard conversations that make no sense etc.
- #7
but honestly, adults write fake-feeling arguments too. they just don’t want anyone to become unlikeable, and fandom intensifies that. readers sometimes treat "this character did something bad" as "the author thinks this character is bad" or "the author endorses this behavior."
- #8
and once writers anticipate that kind of response, they may start pre-defending their couple in hopes of avoiding it. which ironically makes a rs feel less intimate, because couples know EXACTLY how to hurt each other, actually hurt each other, and deal with the consequences.
- #9
obviously, "toxic" doesn't automatically mean "realistic", but closeness creates leverage. if someone knows what you’re insecure about, what you’re afraid of, what you need reassurance about, then during a bad enough argument they may really hit that nerve, intentionally or not.
- #10
so is the root of the "problem" really age or inexperience? no, i don't think so. i think this is just what happens when fights are written around plot convenience (wanting to get somewhere and getting there the fastest) instead of conflict resolution and psychology.
- #11
that's also when you get arguments where one refuses to explain something that would take ten seconds, the other suddenly becomes wildly cruel unprovoked, or both characters speak to each other like they’re in court instead of just being emotionally dysregulated for a while.
- #12
messiness is hard to write well, but a writer should be able to understand why each character is reacting the way they are, and not necessarily in equal moral correctness. one of them being in the wrong more is perfectly fine and real. don't be afraid of that!
- #13
like, yes, people in close rs know each other’s weak spots, misinterpret things through old trauma, say shit harsher than they meant, get stubborn because apologies feel humiliating. even so, they can love someone deeply and still behave badly toward them in a specific moment.
- #14
just make sure something has changed afterwards. they understand each other better, trust is damaged, boundaries are set, old trauma resurfaces, one realizes they were wrong, etc. if the fight can disappear from the story without affecting either character, what's the point?
- #15
TLDR: if a fictional couple fight doesn't feel realistic, it's probably because that writer is trying to preserve character likability instead of preserving character truth. which are not always the same thing. don't be scared. make your couples fight!