The Wirtz-situation is a train wreck. It's a mixture of wrong expectations, incorrect role and playstyle, resulting…
Summary
Florian Wirtz's struggles at Liverpool stem from three interconnected issues: he's been miscast in an isolated attacking midfield role that doesn't suit his roaming, team-dependent creative style, his confidence has been shaken by the tactical mismatch causing unnatural play, and his teammates appear disconnected from him both in decision-making and interpersonal dynamics. The 150M transfer fee created unrealistic expectations for individual brilliance when Wirtz thrives as a positional floater who needs team structure and understanding to function at his best.
Summarized by ThreadOut AI from the full thread. May miss nuance — read the thread below.
- #1
The Wirtz-situation is a train wreck. It's a mixture of wrong expectations, incorrect role and playstyle, resulting confidence issues. And, tragically, it looks as if his teammates *don't want to play with him.* None of these are mega bad, but they're adding up. Thread:
- #2
Point 1, Expectations & Role: Wirtz is no 150M-player *as an INDIVIDUAL creator*. He is not an elite athlete. He is nimble, quick and can run, but he is not going to demolish PL-defenders in open space. He is absolutely astonishing as a team player. He has an unusual profile:
- #3
He can create from literally *anywhere*. And he is amazing in picking when to appear where. At Leverkusen he moved from wing to wing, FB, DMF, half-spaces, attacking center. Pin him to a definitive position and you lose a big deal of what makes him special. Let him float.
- #4
He is amazing in finding advantages on the pitch, but he also NEEDS advantages. Put him in a strict position within a non- or semi-functional team and he needs to create from neutral, balanced and predictable situations. He will be okay doing that, but far away from 150M.
- #5
Here's a slide from my Leverkusen-seminar 2y ago. His role was perfect for him in so many ways. Now, go through the list, which of these apply to current Liverpool? The 5th SHOULD apply, the 2nd as well but it doesn't. All other points are the opposite now.
- #6
Against City, Liverpool played a wing-focused game with high distances, lack of central presence, very little potential for combinations where Wirtz was pinned into the 10 where he rarely found tight spaces, but was isolated in clear 1v1-assignments. All of that is bad for him.
- #7
People think "position", but the 10 in Liverpool's current playstyle is an isolated one. It would be good for someone like Özil, maybe Bergkamp. Players who are patiently waiting for their moment. Or a Cherki/Ronaldinho-type of player who creates on his own from dribbling.
- #8
It's not a good role for a player who wants to have a ton of touches, lots of options and consistent influence everywhere. That is not an excuse for Wirtz, it's just blatantly obvious if you know him. Even Messi struggled when he was simply "put on the 10" for Argentina.
- #9
For creators and strikers, you need the right rhythm, the right playstyle, the right teammates. It's not just about "put them into the right position and this will do". Tons of similar examples in history. Bergkamp at Inter. Ibrahimovic at Barca. Bruno Fernandes at the WC. Etc.
- #10
The "Wirtz is just shit" crowd will be unhappy with that and I admit that there are some things in his game that didn't fully translate to EPL simply because of level. He's crazy good in maximising a superiority over a defender. That's missing if he is not superior.
- #11
I was talking about this before: I do think "Bundesliga-tax" is real to some degree. It would have been naive to expect the SAME type of dominance that Wirtz had at Leverkusen. But: He has a lot of tools to play around that. He does not NEED to have...
Martin Rafelt@MartinRafelt · Jul 5, 2024Bundesliga-players with the most goals in the Euro yet, by far, with the EPL being only third placed. Here's a theory I have, about player-levels in general and EPL/BL in particular. Short: The physical level in the EPL is so high, that good players don't survive there.
- #12
...superiority over defenders because he is so amazingly good in dodging defenders and finding space. I don't think the "he can't handle the physicality" or "there is no space in the EPL" are fully true and imo they are not TOO relevant for his issues.
- #13
If you look closely, in the majority of his action he IS able to find space and he is NOT physically bullied. These problematic moments exist, but they're blown out of proportion. Even if there's a drastic issue here, 80-90% of his actions are not affected by it.
- #14
That issue though makes it even more important to have a role for him where he can roam around, create overloads, influence through movement and decisions... Basically, he lost 20% of his game in the EPL and now that exact part is the thing he is supposed to use the most.
- #15
Point 2, Rhythm & Confidence: Great creative play functions on intuition. It's fast, natural and does not allow for "double thinking". You don't have time to reflect if your decision is correct. If you have an idea, you have to act immediately. Now, if you are not allowed to...
- #16
...do what you're used to. And then your teammates don't behave as you expect. And then what you expect to work, suddenly does not work anymore. And then you are told to change. Then, your fast inutitive acting is disturbed. You start double thinking because you're asked to.
- #17
You don't have time to create a sense for the rhythm of the game, because you're expected to deliver immediately. You're trying to force things, you start to play unnatural, don't follow your intuition anymore. I honestly think that Wirtz is affected by that much less than...
- #18
...other players I have experienced. I saw many players fall into a big hole when the environment asked them to not do anymore what they were used to do. Wirtz seems *mostly* still quite natural, but not fully. I think his most blatant mistakes are a result of that.
- #19
Like this failed pass in the 3rd minute, that's just him trying to make something happen from a valuable position. Pressure -> Ambition -> Urgency take over where normally he will easily spot that the pass is not there, that the teammate is going wide.
- #20
These are the type of errors that make you look dumb. It's what the people remember even if you have just a few of them in your game. And then a player receives backlash and the issue becomes worse. It's an important dimension in the modern environment. (With social media etc.)
- #21
That, again, is not an excuse, it's something that players of that level need to deal with. But it explains why Wirtz looks so different. And especially creative decision-makers have the most difficult time to handle that. It was visible for Lamine in the WC final too. Flow.
- #22
Point 3, Connection with the team: Now that is the most speculative thing, but in the City-game this was the reason for many failed actions of him and there just were some very strange moments in that game. Either they don't like him or they just think very differently. Or both.
- #23
Here's the craziest one, should have been an assist for him. He receives freely, spots Munoz with a clear advantage, plays a quick pass with two touches and then..Munoz just stops right before the pass is played. This was so basic and a huge opportunity. strange.
- #24
Another one where Koumas reacts late even though he's the most obvious passing option, then he DOES move towards the ball but just stops even when he's still in front of the CB. People tend to be super critical of "failed passes" like that, but imo that's 100% on the receiver.
- #25
These one MIGHT be Munoz attempting to change his run towards the inside and Koumas trying to block the CB to take the ball straight towards the goal. But then there are also huge opportunities where the team just ignores Wirtz as an obvious best choice.
- #26
We don't know what's happening within the team, but there are a few plausible reasons for that. Jürgen Klopp said the team was not prioritizing football after Diogo Jota's death. Then Wirtz might not be the type of person and not have the type of skillset (...)
- #27
..that is highly valued from the team. I think you can quickly look stupid in training when there's Szoboszlai right next to you. "He's the most expensive guy and we need to support him?" Stuff like that.
- #28
There's also a cultural level to that. As I described in that thread, the EPL culture is quite focused on physicality, also on fulfilling pre-defined roles. (German football is more pragmatic and vague: If a player works, he works.)
Martin Rafelt@MartinRafelt · Jul 5, 2024Also, in my opinion, the EPL hurts itself by over-selecting athletic ability, but at the same time, it's difficult to break this pattern, because at this point that's just the reality the clubs have to deal with. They trapped themselves. Only Pascal Groß can save them now.
- #29
I'm sure that's not helping his standing inside the team. A few important players thinking, he's too small, too slow, too whatever. Then a lack of intersocial connections maybe. And you may become alienated by the guy. Of course, this should not affect a professional...
- #30
on the pitch, but humans are human. You play differently with a friend or a guy that you trust, it's instinct. You see them more, your emotional state is better. You can't fully shut that down just because you're a professional player. When split seconds matter, emotions matter.
- #31
Ultimately, if you buy a bunch of players who were good before and they all stop being good, it's always a team issue, not a player issue. Fix that first. Then see how the guys actually can perform. Noone in football can do it without the team and much less so attackers.