Did you know the death rate from measles declined by 98% before the measles vaccine was introduced? Here, Aaron Siri…
Summary
This thread argues that measles mortality declined significantly before vaccine introduction due to improved nutrition and sanitation, and critiques vaccine trial designs for using inadequate control groups and short monitoring periods. The author contends that medicine's institutional attachment to vaccines functions as a quasi-religious belief system that discourages critical examination of vaccine safety evidence.
Summarized by ThreadOut AI from the full thread. May miss nuance — read the thread below.
- #1
Did you know the death rate from measles declined by 98% before the measles vaccine was introduced? Here, Aaron Siri discusses that earlier decline and the contributions of better nutrition, sanitation and clean water. The decline had nothing to do with vaccines. Why then does the medical field have such a rigid ideological attachment to vaccines? The history helps explain it. But that history is only part of the problem. We also need to examine how vaccine safety is established, and what happens when the studies cannot answer the questions patients and their families are asking. 🧵
- #2
One of the most consequential details in a vaccine trial is what the control group receives. For example, the main prelicensure study for Prevnar 7 used another experimental vaccine as its comparator. Hepatitis B studies monitored for side effects for only 4–5 days. Those choices determine which safety questions a study can answer. Here I examine those trial designs and the history of medicine’s attachment to vaccination: midwesterndoctor.com/p/why-have-vac…
- #3
One explanation for medicine’s attachment to vaccines is that they occupy a central place in the profession’s account of how it rescued humanity from infectious disease. In this presentation, Secretary Kennedy challenges that account. I believe the resistance to examining it is partly explained by how closely it is tied to medicine’s status and authority. Dr. Suzanne Humphries encountered a revealing example. When she raised concerns about kidney failure following flu shots, a colleague responded by invoking the successes of smallpox and polio vaccination. Those were different vaccines and different questions. Yet their reputation was being used to dismiss the clinical problem she was trying to investigate.
- #4
Before flu-shot mandates became widespread, many doctors I knew did not receive the vaccine. They felt its benefits were negligible, had concerns about its risks, and thought a mandate made little sense. This 2009 CNN segment shows New York healthcare workers openly protesting an annual flu-shot requirement. It is remarkable how quickly a mandate was able to shift critical thinking on this topic into an embrace of vaccination. In my article, I discuss how professional expectations can reinforce an existing belief: once doctors have accepted a practice themselves and promoted it to patients, reconsidering it becomes much more personally difficult: midwesterndoctor.com/p/why-have-vac…
- #5
I believe part of medicine’s resistance to questioning vaccines comes from how much doctors have personally invested in them. After years of training and vaccinating patients, acknowledging that a practice you supported may have caused harm can be profoundly difficult. Cognitive dissonance can lead doctors to defend an existing belief rather than reconsider the evidence. This helps explain why a disagreement about a medical product can become so personal. midwesterndoctor.com/p/why-have-vac…
- #6
That attachment also shapes how evidence is interpreted. I examine the use of other vaccines as trial comparators, short monitoring windows, and the arguments used to dismiss research that challenges prevailing assumptions. Aaron Siri’s investigations bring many of these contradictions into focus. I also explain how they fit together, and why I believe vaccination has acquired such a religious character within medicine. midwesterndoctor.com/p/why-have-vac…
- #7
In Dr. Robert Mendelsohn's 1979 book, Confessions of a Medical Heretic, he argued that medicine often functioned as a religion, with doctors as priests, hospitals as temples, and practices that patients were expected to accept on faith. Of these points, I spent by far the most time pondering his argument vaccines were medicine’s holy water. Here, Tucker Carlson and Cheryl Hines discuss that same religious dimension. Mendelsohn also described how doctors who challenged established practices could be treated as heretics. Nonetheless, many of the issues Mendelsohn highlighted persist to the present day.
- #8
I’ve long observed many problems in science originate from an erroneous interpretation of a philosophical concept. Consider evidence-based medicine. Its 1996 definition called for integrating clinical expertise with the best available external evidence, while taking account of the individual patient’s circumstances, rights and preferences. It did not reduce medical judgment to repeating an expert’s conclusion. In my article, I discuss the problem of dismissing observational vaccine research because it is not a randomized trial while also rejecting proposed randomized comparisons on ethical grounds: midwesterndoctor.com/p/why-have-vac… The limitations of an observational study still matter. But asking for research that will not be conducted leaves the original question unanswered. I believe dismissing the available observational research solely because it is not a placebo-controlled trial distorts the original intent of evidence-based medicine.
- #9
The ethical objection to placebo trials creates another difficulty. If withholding a vaccine is considered unacceptable, what research will be used to answer the outstanding questions about it? Large existing datasets offer one way to study health outcomes without assigning children to receive or forgo a vaccine. Siri’s efforts to obtain access to such data are one of the subjects I discuss. Those comparisons require attention to differences between the groups, but access to the data is a prerequisite for examining them at all. The absence of evidence is not the evidence of absence. The distinction between those two positions is profoundly consequential for patients.
- #10
A related issue is the use of another vaccine or an aluminum-containing preparation as the control in a vaccine trial. In the examples I discuss, Prevnar 7 was compared with another experimental vaccine, while Gardasil trials included an aluminum-containing comparator. A small difference between two groups tells us something about those two groups. It does not, by itself, establish how either compares with receiving neither intervention. Likewise, the 4–5-day monitoring windows in the hepatitis B studies I discuss cannot resolve questions about conditions that develop much later. The comparator and the monitoring window limit what these studies can establish about safety. Note: a medical condition occurring after vaccination is not automatically caused by it. Determining causation is precisely why the comparison group and follow-up matter.
- #11
I have always tried to give readers the information needed to reach their own conclusions rather than pressure them to adopt mine. For this article, I brought together Mendelsohn’s 1979 critique, Humphries’ hospital experience, and Aaron Siri’s work on the legal and scientific assumptions surrounding vaccination. I wrote this article in part because of the vital work Aaron Siri has done over the years to support vaccine safety, and in part because his book ties together critical pieces around the religious ritual of vaccination. Here I examine that history, the specific problems with safety research, and why questioning vaccination can provoke such an intense institutional response: midwesterndoctor.com/p/why-have-vac…
- #12
We need real medicine so I've dedicated myself to exposing Pharma corruption and revealing life-changing therapies the medical cartel buried. If you want to support this mission please give me (@MidwesternDoc) a follow and visit me on Substack! midwesterndoctor.com