Skip to content
Mark Goldfeder@MarkGoldfeder · Sep 8, 2026

Dear @Ed_Miliband, Congratulations. Your pathetic, performative politics just poked a real bear. Your bans puts…

30 tweets4 min read♥ 2.7Koriginal

Summary

A lengthy critique argues that UK Energy Secretary Ed Miliband's ban on settlement goods puts British businesses in legal jeopardy by conflicting with US anti-boycott laws, while questioning the legal basis for the ban and pointing out inconsistencies in how Britain treats commerce in disputed territories.

Summarized by ThreadOut AI from the full thread. May miss nuance — read the thread below.

  1. #1

    Dear @Ed_Miliband, Congratulations. Your pathetic, performative politics just poked a real bear. Your bans puts British businesses on a collision course with American antiboycott law. Let me explain what you’ve just walked them into. 🧵

    Ed Miliband@Ed_Miliband · Sep 8, 2026

    The UK will stand up for what is right.

  2. #2

    @Ed_Miliband You invoke international law as though those words end the discussion. They begin it. What rule requires this particular ban? How has Britain applied that rule elsewhere? And what happens when British demands collide with American law?

  3. #3

    @Ed_Miliband The argument starts with an instrument Britain itself administered: the Mandate for Palestine. Article 6 directed Britain to encourage Jewish settlement on the land while protecting other inhabitants’ rights.

  4. #4

    @Ed_Miliband Article 80 of the UN Charter preserved existing rights under international instruments.

  5. #5

    @Ed_Miliband When Israel declared independence in 1948 it was immediately attacked by five Arab nations. The UN blamed the Arabs for the violence and aggression meant to forcefully take land, and the Spokesman for the Arab Higher Committee readily agreed.

  6. #6

    If there was ever an occupation, it happened between 1948 and 1967, when two of the invading Arab armies, Jordan (West Bank) and Egypt (Gaza Strip) occupied territory that they had taken through aggressive action – the kind of aggressive action explicitly forbidden under international law.

  7. #7

    @Ed_Miliband In 1967, Israel regained those territories in what was undisputedly a defensive war under Article 51. In 1967 then, Israel legitimately regained sovereignty having never lost title.

  8. #8

    @Ed_Miliband But even setting aside the facts and the history, Article 49(6) of the Fourth Geneva Convention prohibits an occupying power from deporting or transferring its own civilian population into occupied territory.

  9. #9

    @Ed_Miliband The Red Cross’s own commentary explains that the clause was written to stop the forced population transfers, not to stop a Jewish family from buying an apartment in Jerusalem.

  10. #10

    @Ed_Miliband And in every other occupation on earth, Turkish Cyprus, Moroccan Western Sahara, Russian-held Ukraine, the occupier’s citizens have moved into the territory, and no one ever called it a violation of Article 49(6).

  11. #11

    @Ed_Miliband You know who agrees with me? British law. Britain’s own Supreme Court considered settlement commerce in Richardson v DPP (2014).

  12. #12

    @Ed_Miliband Protesters occupied a London shop selling these products arguing that it was aiding the transfer of Israelis into occupied territory. A unanimous Supreme Court held that no such crime had been shown and that none had anything to do with the ordinary business of selling goods.

  13. #13

    @Ed_Miliband The highest court in Britain looked for a crime in selling settlement goods and did not find one.

  14. #14

    @Ed_Miliband Now consider Western Sahara. Morocco has controlled most of it since 1975. Britain’s trade agreement extends preferential treatment to products from Western Sahara under Moroccan customs control. So Britain knows how to facilitate commerce in disputed territory.

  15. #15

    Interesting, because when campaigners challenged that arrangement, the British government defended it in court and won in 2022. So Britain has defended preferential trade involving one territorial occupation while demanding commercial exclusion involving another alleged occupation.

  16. #16

    @Ed_Miliband Explain the principle, @10DowningStreet. A tariff preference when Morocco controls the territory. A trade ban when Israel does.

  17. #17

    @Ed_Miliband @10DowningStreet Now, the services ban is where Britain runs right into American law. Congress wrote the anti-boycott laws in the 1970s to stop the Arab League from conscripting American companies into its boycott of Israel.

  18. #18

    Section 999 of the Internal Revenue Code requires @USTreasury and @SecScottBessent to list countries that require cooperation with an international boycott and strips tax benefits from any taxpayer who cooperates.

  19. #19

    @Ed_Miliband @10DowningStreet @USTreasury @SecScottBessent Meanwhile, the Department of @CommerceGov and @HowardLutnick's regulations reach any foreign subsidiary “controlled in fact” by an American parent.

  20. #20

    @Ed_Miliband @10DowningStreet @USTreasury @SecScottBessent @CommerceGov @howardlutnick So a London bank owned in NY that refuses to finance a building in a Jewish neighborhood of Jerusalem because British law tells it to is, under the regulations, an American person breaking American law.

  21. #21

    @Ed_Miliband @10DowningStreet @USTreasury @SecScottBessent @CommerceGov @howardlutnick And yes, in case you were wondering, in 2016 Congress defined boycotts of Israel to include measures aimed at anyone doing business “in any territory controlled by Israel.”

  22. #22

    @Ed_Miliband @10DowningStreet @USTreasury @SecScottBessent @CommerceGov @howardlutnick So Washington already has the tools. When Turkey announced a trade embargo on Israel in 2024, Commerce issued an antiboycott advisory telling American companies in Turkey what they could not do and what they had to report.

  23. #23

    @Ed_Miliband @10DowningStreet @USTreasury @SecScottBessent @CommerceGov @howardlutnick Treasury just published its boycott list on Aug 10; it names eight countries. The @StateDept said of Ireland’s bill in July that the US “firmly opposes this effort and rejects any efforts to economically isolate, or discriminate against, Israel.”

  24. #24

    @Ed_Miliband @10DowningStreet @USTreasury @SecScottBessent @CommerceGov @howardlutnick @StateDept London should get the same statement, then the same advisory, and, if the services ban becomes law, a place on the Treasury list.

  25. #25

    In the meantime, the states will also not wait. Many have anti-boycott statutes that reach anyone limiting commercial relations with businesses in Israeli-controlled territories, and those laws bar such companies from state contracts, require state pension funds to divest from them, or both.

  26. #26

    @Ed_Miliband @10DowningStreet @USTreasury @SecScottBessent @CommerceGov @howardlutnick @StateDept Florida’s alone knocked Airbnb off the state’s approved list in 2019 until it reversed its settlement policy, and British companies are the top foreign investor in Florida, with more than 88,000 jobs there. @RepFine @RonDeSantis

  27. #27

    British lawyers will answer that federal law preempts state rules on compliance with foreign boycotts, and it does. BUT it does not preempt state laws against discrimination, which is how most of these statutes are written. And the rest run in the same direction as federal policy.

  28. #28

    The Supreme Court strikes down state laws that obstruct Washington’s foreign policy, not state laws that carry it out. A British bank that announces it has stopped serving Jerusalem to satisfy London will be answering to Tallahassee well before Treasury has finished its paperwork.

  29. #29

    @Ed_Miliband @10DowningStreet @USTreasury @SecScottBessent @CommerceGov @howardlutnick @StateDept @RepFine @RonDeSantis Palestinian workers belong in this discussion too. Businesses targeted by these restrictions employ Palestinians. Cutting off customers, financing or services can threaten their jobs. Way to go, Ed.

  30. #30

    @Ed_Miliband @10DowningStreet @USTreasury @SecScottBessent @CommerceGov @howardlutnick @StateDept @RepFine @RonDeSantis Turns out you don’t have to be a royal to royally screw things up. Making British businesses pay for your political posturing is quite the crowning achievement for your first 50 days.