Skip to content
@jackbutcher@jackbutcher · Jan 7, 2023

Transparency time: Working on the next iteration of Checks and itching to share some of the ideas/revisions/thinking.…

31 tweets4 min read♥ 2.1Koriginal

Summary

Artist shares behind-the-scenes process of developing the next iteration of their "Checks" NFT artwork, exploring ideas around supply reduction mechanics, scarcity, and on-chain art generation without destroying original works.

Summarized by ThreadOut AI from the full thread. May miss nuance — read the thread below.

  1. #1

    Transparency time: Working on the next iteration of Checks and itching to share some of the ideas/revisions/thinking. Went back and forth on doing this — but ultimately, the process is as much a part of the art as the art itself, so will be sharing more in the thread below.

  2. #2

    This began life as a single piece of artwork, captioned: "This artwork may or may not be notable" Priced at $8 per edition, a nod to the new meta of "purchasing" status. No prizes for guessing the very notable "legacy" artist that inspired the visual.

  3. #3

    An edition limited by time only (a nod to the idea that the only requirement to get a check, was $8). It ran 24 for hours on @ourZORA, and 16,031 identical pieces were minted.

  4. #4

    Candidly, as is always the case — you have no idea how the world will react to something you made, so that number could have also been very different. To have the world "validate" an idea that you have thought deeply about (but always second guess) is a profound experience.

  5. #5

    This piece from March 2021 "NFTs, explained." contains the genesis of this idea: Since then I have been exploring the overlap between social contracts, NFTs, digital provenance, what art is, how it evolves, and who decides all of the above. foundation.app/@visualizevalu…

  6. #6

    Obviously all of this has been massively controversial, which is exactly why it's fertile ground for making art.

  7. #7

    Bit of context setting out of the way, back to the Checks idea. One of the other big recurring themes in my work @visualizevalue has been positive-sum games vs. status games, inspired heavily by the writings of @naval:

    Naval@naval · Jan 11, 2018

    Wealth creation is an evolutionarily recent positive-sum game. Status is an old zero-sum game. Those attacking wealth creation are often just seeking status.

  8. #8

    @visualizevalue @naval It's my belief that on a long time horizon, permissionless markets are a positive sum game, but in the short term they can feel incredibly zero sum. Which led me to my first idea (that didn't make the cut) for an extension of Checks, an on-chain status game:

  9. #9

    @visualizevalue @naval While I think this would make a great artistic statement, it leaves the possibility open for someone to burn the art they purchased and get nothing in return. It's the original piece, sliced in to 80 1/1s — distributed to the top 80 burners of the edition. Not quite right.

  10. #10

    @visualizevalue @naval So back to the creative process, but this time starting with some numbers: There are 2,561 owners of the original Checks piece at time of writing. 16,031 in circulation. ~6 per person. Each artwork contains 80 checks.

  11. #11

    @visualizevalue @naval In my agency art director days, I always used to start with wikipedia if I was trying to find a creative angle on something that was rooted in truth. Full transparency, the 80 checks in the original piece were not intentional so this is a fully reverse engineered rationale:

  12. #12

    The semi-perfect number above gave me an idea that I am still working on, and will continue to document in this thread shortly. Thanks for reading this far, and thanks for collecting my work. I appreciate it more than I can articulate.

  13. #13

    80 as a semiperfect number explained below: "a natural number n that is equal to the sum of all or some of its proper divisors"

  14. #14

    A concept that gives us some constraints to work within.

  15. #15

    Also worth noting how paradoxically perfect the word "semiperfect" is for this. A mathematical oxymoron.

  16. #16

    If you have been around NFTs for a while, you'll recall Damian Hirst's "The Currency" — which worked like this: Burn the NFT, get the physical, or keep the NFT, and the physical gets burned. Of the original 10,000, there are 1,846 NFTs left. opensea.io/collection/the…

  17. #17

    The supply stays the "same" but the market reveals its preference for each medium in the process. (Numbers above are apparently not correct, collection is split across a couple of chains/not displaying perfectly on OS, anyone who knows actual numbers please enlighten me)

  18. #18

    A lengthier detour than planned, correction below: The majority of the market opted for the physical version. x.com/watspoons/stat…

  19. #19

    This is not what we are going to do, but an important precedent to recognize. Next steps for Checks — checking technical feasibility on a few things, and double checking some math. Will be back to share soon, thanks for reading.

  20. #20

    Some meta-transparency on this thread to leave you with.

  21. #21

    To extend the premise of the original piece — the question we are trying to answer is: are checks more desirable if they are harder to get? We can find out by incentivizing a reduction in supply.

  22. #22

    But we want to do it without destroying anything in the process.

  23. #23

    Some new wireframe sketches informed by our semiperfect concept, and true to the invisible grid of the original piece: 80, 40, 20, 10, 5, 4, 1, 0

  24. #24

    Testing...

  25. #25

    Recruited the legendary @jalil_eth & @traf to build some proper tech for the next round. Below courtesy of the giga talented @traf (all this animation is done in-browser)

  26. #26

    @jalil_eth @traf Current working mechanic (not final): Burn your edition for an on-chain original. Burn 2 originals for the next smallest edition original. 80 > 40 > 20 > 10 > 5 > 4 > 1 Stop wherever you like.

  27. #27

    @jalil_eth @traf Hard to explain in text so here's a visual (again, a work in progress):

  28. #28

    @jalil_eth @traf What this does: rewards every collector, creates new, original, on-chain work, and every interaction either maintains or reduces supply.

  29. #29

    An idea for everyone following along in real-time, minting some of the concept sketches as a free claim for holders. Interesting?

  30. #30

    Scratch that, not interesting. Right click save only. A few closeups of @jalil_eth's color tests for on-chain generation of new originals using only the 80 colors from the first piece: 80s (left) 20s (right)

  31. #31

    @jalil_eth Math Q: How many possible permutations of the 80 grid are there? Assuming 80 colors w/ duplicates allowed, 80 checks, 80 positions.